Japan dolphin slaughter draws tough rebuke from Ambassador Kennedy

Fishermen in Japan have begun slaughtering dozens of bottlenose dolphins, ignoring protesters’ calls to spare the animals and a rare public show of concern by the US government.

The annual hunt in Taiji, a picturesque whaling town on the Pacific coast, began early Tuesday morning, according to activists from the Sea Shepherd marine conservation group who are monitoring the fishermen. 

As many as 250 dolphins were herded into a secluded cove late last week; some were selected for sale to aquariums and marine parks, but by the end of Tuesday, about 40 dolphins had been killed in the cull, which is conducted mostly out of view beneath tarpaulin covers. More than 100 remaining mammals – mainly young calves – were driven back out to sea.

The hunt has been in the international spotlight since the 2009 release of "The Cove," an Oscar-winning documentary about the town’s dolphin-hunting tradition and attempts to end it.

This year’s slaughter attracted more attention than usual after US Ambassador Caroline Kennedy publicly criticized the methods used in the hunt. Ms. Kennedy, who only recently took up her post, was seen as an inexperienced but popular appointment because of her family background and close ties to President Barack Obama. Her willingness to enter the fray over issues that have attracted mainly private criticism from Washington – as well as the embassy's recent statement criticizing Prime Minister Shinzo Abe’s visit last month to a controversial war shrine – has forced senior Japanese officials on the defensive.

'Inhumaneness'

In a tweet sent out at the weekend, Kennedy wrote: 

Kennedy was referring to the practice, long used in Taiji, of herding pods of dolphins into shallow water, where the exhausted animals are left for up to a few days before being killed.

Hunters kill the mammals by driving metal poles through their spinal cords – a practice they say is more humane and reduces bleeding – but activists claim it can take 20-30 minutes for them to die.

Kennedy may get to see the practice firsthand following reports that fishermen in Taiji, who often refuse to talk to reporters, would welcome her.

“I want her to come and visit so that she can understand how we make a living from it," a local fisheries official told Agence France-Presse on condition of anonymity. "Many fishermen make a living from the hunting, and many others also earn their living by working at food processing factories.”

Kennedy's criticism of the visit to Yasukuni Shrine, which Japan's neighbors argue is a symbol of its unrepentant aggression during World War II, prompted Japan’s foreign minister to call her while she was on vacation to explain Tokyo’s position.

Chief Cabinet Secretary Yoshihide Suga pointed out that the 1986 ban on commercial whaling did not apply to dolphins and other small cetaceans, adding that the mammals were not endangered.

"Dolphin fishing is one of Japan's traditional fishing techniques and is carried out appropriately in accordance with the law," Mr. Suga told reporters. "We will explain our stance to the American side."

On Tuesday, the governor of Wakayama prefecture, where Taiji is located, rejected Kennedy’s concerns. "Dietary culture varies and it is the wisdom of civilization to mutually respect others' standpoints unless the world faces a lack of resources," Yoshinobu Nisaka told reporters. "We take away the lives of animals like of cows and pigs daily. It is not appropriate to say only dolphin hunting is cruel.”

Kennedy quickly found an ally in her counterpart from Britain, Tim Hitchens, who took to Twitter to voice his opposition. "UK opposes all forms of dolphin and porpoise drives; they cause terrible suffering. We regularly raise [the issue] with Japan,” he wrote.

Don't forget the whales

Japan is also coming under international pressure to end its annual pursuit of bigger whales in the Antarctic. The International Court of Justice in The Hague is expected to rule within months on an Australian government attempt to ban the Antarctic hunt.

A clause in the International Whaling Commission moratorium allows Japan to kill just under 1,000 large whales, mainly minke, every year for what it calls “scientific research.” The meat is sold legally in Japanese supermarkets and restaurants.

Japan also kills up to 20,000 small cetaceans every year in its coastal waters. Sea Shepherd said that 176 marine mammals had been killed so far this season.
Louie Psihoyos, who directed "The Cove," says the slaughter is “reprehensible,” citing evidence that dolphin meat contains high levels of mercury.

“The hunters claim they are poor and need the meat to feed their families, but who would feed poison to their children and parents?” he says. “They also claim they are family men, but they have just massacred a whole pod full of families.”