The rise of trading quote spam

High-frequency quoting that has skyrocketed recently, leading some in the US to think it might be time for a financial non-transaction tax similar to the one in France. The French will also impose a tax on traders who submit too many unfilled quotes.

A trader works on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange, in this June 2012 file photo in New York City. High-frequency quoting that has skyrocketed recently, leading some in the US to think it might be time for a financial non-transaction tax, like France implemented.

Mary Altaffer/AP

August 11, 2012

On Monday, I posted a lovely animated gif from Nanex showing the rise of high-frequency trading. What I failed to mention is that graph doesn’t show completed trades. It shows quotes.

And according to another nice chart from Nanex, it’s high-frequency quoting that has skyrocketed, not trading.

The number of unexecuted quotes, many allegedly not intended to be executed, has thus skyrocketed.

Why many in Ukraine oppose a ‘land for peace’ formula to end the war

France recently took steps to try to deter the rise in quotes. In addition to a financial transactions tax it, France will also impose a tax on traders who submit too many unfilled quotes.

In short, France will levy a financial non-transaction tax.