Police brutality: Former officer pleads guilty in Tyre Nichols case

Desmond Mills Jr., a former Memphis police officer, pleaded guilty in the fatal beating of Tyre Nichols after a traffic stop in January 2023. He is the first of the five officers charged to admit guilt. Prosecutors recommended a 15-year sentence. 

First Look

A former Memphis police officer pleaded guilty Nov. 2 in the fatal beating of Tyre Nichols in exchange for prosecutors recommending a 15-year sentence, becoming the first of five officers charged in the case to admit guilt.

Desmond Mills Jr. entered his plea during a hearing at the Memphis federal courthouse as part of a larger agreement under which he will also plead guilty to related charges in state court. It wasn’t immediately clear if any of the other officers would follow suit. Attorneys for three of the officers declined to comment and William Massey, the lawyer for Emmitt Martin, said in a text message that they “will stay the course” with the former officer’s criminal defense.

Mr. Mills pleaded guilty to federal charges of excessive force and obstruction of justice and agreed to cooperate with prosecutors. The final sentencing decision rests with the judge. Mr. Mills remains free on bail ahead of his May 22 sentencing hearing.

Mr. Nichols’ mother, RowVaughn Wells, shook as she described hearing how five large men beat her skinny son.

“This one today was very difficult for me because this was really the first time I actually heard somebody tell and say what they actually did to my son,” she told reporters outside the courthouse. “So, this was very difficult. But I’m hoping that Mr. Mills, it was his conscience that allowed him to make this plea agreement, and not because of his lawyers telling him it was the right thing to do.”

Caught on police video, the beating of Mr. Nichols in January was one in a string of violent encounters between police and Black people that sparked protests and renewed debate about police brutality and the need for police reform in the United States. The five former officers who were charged also are Black.

Mr. Mills and four other former Memphis Police Department officers were charged in federal court with using excessive force, failing to intervene, deliberate indifference, and conspiring to lie, as well as obstruction of justice after they were caught on camera punching, kicking, and beating Mr. Nichols on Jan. 7. He died three days later.

The five – Mr. Mills, Mr. Martin, Tadarrius Bean, Demetrius Haley, and Justin Smith – pleaded not guilty to second-degree murder and other charges in state court. Mr. Mills is the first to agree to plead guilty.

Mr. Nichols’ mother and her husband said the possibility of 15 years in prison is “a start.” Mr. Nichols’ stepfather, Rodney Wells, noted that Mr. Mills has a family, with three children 6 years old and younger.

“Fifteen years is a long time with no parole,” Mr. Wells said at the news conference. “That’s going to affect his family, that’s going to affect him.”

Blake Ballin, Mr. Mills’ defense attorney, told reporters that Mr. Mills “understands he did something wrong and he’s taking responsibility for it.” Mr. Ballin added that there’s “overwhelming evidence of the guilt of people involved here,” and if authorities need Mr. Mills to testify at a possible trial, he will.

Shelby County District Attorney Steve Mulroy said Mr. Mills’ cooperation “probably would incentivize” the other officers to consider plea deals too. Mr. Mills will also cooperate in the U.S. Department of Justice’s investigation into the Memphis Police Department, which Mr. Mulroy said should lead to systemic reform.

Mr. Mulroy said the defendants hold “different levels of responsibility” in Mr. Nichols’ death and that Mr. Mills “is not the worst of the five” officers charged.

Ben Crump, the attorney for Mr. Nichols’ family, said Mr. Mills’ decision continues the “sea change” witnessed after George Floyd’s death, when the Minneapolis police chief testified during former Officer Derek Chauvin’s murder trial that he had violated departmental policy, values, and principles.

“The precedent that’s being set now – police officers tell the truth, even if that means piercing the blue veil,” Mr. Crump told reporters.

The plea agreement sets out Mr. Mills’ role in the fatal beating, detailing how he pepper-sprayed Mr. Nichols three times before pulling out a baton and yelling, “I’m about to baton the [expletive] out of you.” He repeatedly struck Mr. Nichols, who was on the ground and surrounded by officers, never giving him an opportunity to comply with the command, “give us your hands!”

After the beating, Mr. Mills and the other officers failed to tell the responding medics that they had beaten Mr. Nichols, instead saying he was on drugs. Meanwhile, among themselves they discussed “taking turns hitting Nichols, hitting Nichols with straight haymakers, and everybody rocking Nichols. During these conversations, the officers discussed hitting Nichols to make him fall and observed that when Nichols did not fall from these blows, they believed they were ‘about to kill’ him,” according to the plea agreement.

Mr. Martin used hand signals to indicate to Mr. Mills that his body camera was still recording. Mr. Mills removed the camera and placed it on the back of a patrol car.

Mr. Mills told supervisors at the scene that he knew Mr. Nichols was in bad shape and he “expressed concerns about Nichols’ survival,” according to the agreement. When the five officers spoke later, they discussed what the body camera recording might show and conspired to mislead investigators. That included agreeing not to report that Mr. Martin had repeatedly struck Mr. Nichols in the head.

After Mr. Nichols’ death, all five officers were fired from the department and the crime-suppression team they were part of was disbanded. The four remaining officers have a May 6 trial date in federal court. A trial has not yet been set in state court.

The officers said they pulled Mr. Nichols over because he was driving recklessly, but Police Chief Cerelyn “CJ” Davis said no evidence was found to support that allegation. Mr. Nichols ran from officers, who tried to restrain him. He pleaded for his mother as he was pummeled just steps from his home.

An autopsy report showed Mr. Nichols died from blows to the head, and that the manner of death was homicide. The report described brain injuries, cuts, and bruises to the head and other parts of the body.

This story was reported by The Associated Press.