2018
October
26
Friday

Monitor Daily Podcast

October 26, 2018
Loading the player...
Clayton Collins
Director of Editorial Innovation

The isolating notion of “the other” spiked again in a week dominated by news of improvised explosive devices.

The US administration weighs blocking asylum-seekers. Race flares as a homestretch issue in the midterms. A blackface comment drops from the lips of a TV media star.

Islamophobia happens not to be the current centerpiece, even though it was stirred into the migrant caravan saga with a mention of “unknown Middle Easterners.” On that particular strain of fear-stoking, though, it’s worth knowing about one graceful teller of a counternarrative.

When Heraa Hashmi, a college student in Colorado, was told by a classmate that “all terrorists are Muslim,” unchecked by others in the Muslim world, she began crafting a response. It took the form last year of a widely seen 712-page spreadsheet detailing Muslim condemnation of violence.

The feedback she got urged her to add nuance. Was she somehow just contributing to the idea of “good” vs. “bad” Muslims? She worried about promoting such “unhelpful binaries,” as she told the Turkish website TRTWorld recently. It struck her that, as she put it, “[w]e sometimes play into this by attempting to present ourselves as ‘moderate Muslims,’ Muslims who only exist in a way that makes other people feel comfortable in their prejudices.”

That idea of blunt binaries bears watching in what seems to be a season of anger. Matt Grossmann wrote this week in FiveThirtyEight that more voters now are running to parties that shape their beliefs rather than reflecting ones that they’ve formed themselves. That can feed “otherness” too. 

Now to our five stories for your Friday. 


You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.

Today's stories

And why we wrote them

Sergio Moraes/Reuters
Supporters of Jair Bolsonaro, far-right lawmaker and presidential candidate of the Social Liberal Party, attend a demonstration Oct. 21 in Rio de Janeiro.

Many voters cast their favorite politician as a bit of a hero – someone uniquely capable of fixing things or moving the country forward. We look at how extending that attitude may threaten democracy. 

The 21 Americans suing the US government have won attention owing largely to their youth and the high profile of their issue. We wanted to look at the questions their case raises about governmental obligation.

Everyone’s watching this Texas race for the way that it sets up as a showdown of leanings. We saw it as an opportunity to look into the staying power of (mostly) positive campaigning.

Melanie Stetson Freeman/Staff
Diane Buchanan, treasurer of the Meadowbrook residents board, stands in the bedroom of the Hudson, Mass., mobile home she has lived in for 18 years. After an investor offered to buy the mobile home park, residents held a ballot on a $8.2 million conversion to cooperative ownership. It passed.

Here’s a piece about persistence. Faced with an investor buyout of their mobile home park, residents of Meadowbrook could have just hoped for the best. Instead, they sought an innovative solution.

On Film

Neal Preston/Warner Bros./AP
Bradley Cooper and Lady Gaga share a moment on screen. “The surprise,” writes the Monitor’s Peter Rainer, “is that, at least for its first half, this newest ‘A Star Is Born’ is so powerfully fresh.”

Head out, hold out for Netflix, or just know what you’re missing. Peter Rainer’s early fall favorites are in. They include a depiction, starring Melissa McCarthy, of the life of writer Lee Israel and a Danish Oscar entry about a police dispatcher trying to help a woman he believes has faced domestic violence.


The Monitor's View

 Victims? Or predators?

Those seem to be the only types of terms that the media and President Trump can use to depict the thousands of Central American migrants trekking in caravans toward the United States.

Viewing them as predators, Mr. Trump seeks stronger border security and aggressive immigration restrictions, perhaps with an eye on the November elections for Congress.

Those who see them as victims point to a harsh life in the Northern Triangle of Central America, composed of Guatemala, Honduras, and El Salvador. They cite a need for the US to hear out any claims for asylum.

Yet there is a third way to see many of the migrants as well as those who remain in Central America. Based on recent evidence, more people in those countries may be viewing themselves as capable agents of progress.

Of all the “push factors” driving the exodus, such as poverty and violence, one root cause is corruption. It enables poor governance and lawless gangs. But in Guatemala, the people have shown since 2006 – through protests, elections, and other activism – that curbing corruption can improve daily living conditions and perhaps deter emigration.

New data from the International Crisis Group (ICG) finds that justice reforms in that country have contributed to a 5 percent average annual decrease in murder rates from 2007 to 2017. The number of “avoided homicides” was more than 4,500 in that period, attributed to reforms aimed largely at corruption.

Among similar countries in Latin America, Guatemala has “bucked the trend toward worsening violence and rising homicide,” concludes an Oct. 25 report by ICG.

Much of the credit goes to Guatemalans demanding the creation of a special United Nations body, the Commission Against Impunity in Guatemala, in 2006. The unusual body has helped bring about legal and institutional reforms as well as assist prosecutors in investigating corrupt officials.

An estimated 80 criminal groups have been disbanded. A president was forced to resign in 2015. And thousands of police have been fired or arrested. The agency’s anti-corruption efforts have damaged the ruling elite’s grip on power and, notably, allowed a new political freedom “for burgeoning social movements among indigenous and campesino communities,” the ICG states.

In Honduras, too, a similar body was set up in 2015. Known as the Mission to Support the Fight Against Corruption and Impunity in Honduras, it began work in 2017 in helping the investigation and adjudication of corruption. In July, a judge jailed three members of Congress, a deputy government minister, and more than a dozen others while they await trial on charges of corruption.

A number of reforms in the country have led to a sharp decline in murder rates since 2011. “Honduras is addressing the underlying conditions driving migration,” says Francisco Palmieri, a career US diplomat nominated to be ambassador to the country.

The US contributes millions of dollars a year for such reforms. At the least, when others judge these countries and their migrants, the people have earned a better description than victim or predator.


A Christian Science Perspective

About this feature

Each weekday, the Monitor includes one clearly labeled religious article offering spiritual insight on contemporary issues, including the news. The publication – in its various forms – is produced for anyone who cares about the progress of the human endeavor around the world and seeks news reported with compassion, intelligence, and an essentially constructive lens. For many, that caring has religious roots. For many, it does not. The Monitor has always embraced both audiences. The Monitor is owned by a church – The First Church of Christ, Scientist, in Boston – whose founder was concerned with both the state of the world and the quality of available news.

Today’s column explores how to find spiritual poise, calm, and clarity in the midst of life’s storms.


A message of love

ALVARO BARRIENTOS/AP
Tamborileros march in the La Tamborrada, a drum festival in the Basque city of San Sebastián in northern Spain. Throughout human history, musical gatherings have served as celebration, preparation, worship, recreation, and more. Percussion is one of the most basic – and oldest – ways to make music. Scientists have found records of skin drums as early as 4000 BC in early ancient Egypt. Drum-making methods have evolved, but the value of drumming has remained firmly at the center of art, culture, and ritual in communities worldwide. For more images of the percussive art, click the blue button below. – Jasmine Heyward/Staff
( The illustrations in today’s Monitor Daily are by Karen Norris. )

A look ahead

Thanks again for being here today. Check in again on Monday. We’ll resume “On the Move,” our global series. What some fail to realize about global migration is that most migrants desperately seek safety in their own country before looking to cross borders. We’ll report from Honduras. 

More issues

2018
October
26
Friday

Give us your feedback

We want to hear, did we miss an angle we should have covered? Should we come back to this topic? Or just give us a rating for this story. We want to hear from you.