2017
August
23
Wednesday

Monitor Daily Podcast

August 23, 2017
Loading the player...

Does academia have a choice when it comes to censorship?

Cambridge University Press, which publishes China Quarterly, agreed recently to block 300 of its “sensitive” articles in the Chinese market.  A CUP official deemed the move “pragmatic,” as the press faced further action if it did not comply with Beijing’s request. But others saw a win for China’s interest in deploying economic clout to silence certain scholarship (think the Tiananmen Square protests). 

When word got out, academics rushed to remind the world’s oldest publishing house, an arm of one of the world’s oldest continuously operating universities, of the perils of ceding to censorship. CUP, which noted “the recent increases in requests of this nature,” unblocked the articles this week. China’s government has not yet responded.

The dust-up involved a small number of articles. But the outcry was rooted in something much larger: increasing pressure from President Xi Jinping to shut down critics and influence the market of ideas at home and abroad. As Chinese students have flocked to Western universities, for example, chapters of the Beijing-linked Chinese Students and Scholars Association have engaged in what some say are campaigns of harassment and censorship on issues that run counter to Beijing’s agenda. 

Those pressures will continue to intensify. But as one Australian professor told the Financial Times, “you have to stand up for your principles and if that hurts your economic bottom line, then so be it.”

Now, to our five stories of the day. 


You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.

Today's stories

And why we wrote them

Readiness is a key feature of military effectiveness. Now questions are being raised about whether demands on the service are being properly matched by resources and training.

Jacob Turcotte/Staff

President Trump's hostile attitude toward the media is well known, even if it's intensifying. But his harsh take on key members of his own party has left many people wondering about the path forward.

Ueslei Marcelino/Reuters
Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro speaks at a rally against US President Trump in Caracas, Venezuela, Aug. 14.

For leftist leaders who vocally admired the Chávez experiment, pressure is rising to acknowledge the meltdown that has occurred in its wake.

Renata Brito/AP
Gabriele Roza, who helped develop the "Museum of Yesterday" app, walks in the renovated port area of Rio de Janeiro. The app seeks to educate visitors about local history and Rio's role during colonial times, slavery, and even recent corruption investigations.

To inform the future, it's important to understand the past. In Rio de Janeiro, there's an app for that – a techie answer to surfacing a history that has literally been paved over but should not be forgotten.

It doesn't seem to jibe with the "go West" model of American dreaming. But employers seeking fresh talent are finding the pull of home to be a powerful recruiting tool, even in areas where new frontiers aren't immediately obvious. 


The Monitor's View

As President Trump launched a “new strategy” in Afghanistan this week, there are signs of progress on an issue he did not target but that is perhaps even more important to Afghanistan’s future – the battle to ease the burdens of corruption.

Last week, a highly ranked general and a key businessman – Gen. Mohammad Moeen Faqir and Abdul Ghafar Dawi – were tried, convicted, and sentenced in an anticorruption court. “These cases show that money and power are not a guarantee,” Attorney General Farid Hamidi told The Washington Post. “We still do not have complete justice in Afghanistan, but we no longer have complete impunity.”

The burden of corruption on hopes and aspirations can feel heavy indeed. Ill-gotten gains may seem the way of the world. But moral courage and truth can find space, sometimes where we least expect them. And when they do, history can turn.

Afghan President Ashraf Ghani made anticorruption a priority when he came to office. For instance, he has established anticorruption courts tasked with issues ranging from bribery and tax collection to false licenses and the rights of retirees.

“This is the most progress they’ve seen in a long time,” says Earl Anthony Wayne, a former deputy ambassador to Afghanistan and global fellow at the Wilson Center in Washington. 

It became clear early in the 16-year Afghanistan War that rampant corruption in the country significantly affected US efforts to bring stability. President George Bush’s efforts to stifle the nation’s drug economy backfired, and President Barack Obama’s repeated calls on then-President Hamid Karzai to crack down on corruption fizzled.

President Trump’s blueprint for America’s longest war explicitly rejects “nation-building” as a goal. It involves a mini-surge of US troops, an end to arbitrary time limits for deployment or withdrawal, and a notice to Pakistan that supporting terrorists will no longer be tolerated. But longtime Afghanistan-watchers say that building confidence in government and rule of law can be one of the most effective antiterror strategies. 

“Helping foster the development of accountable institutions that are responsive to the people and subject to a relatively equitable rule of law is critical,” says Sarah Chayes, senior associate in the Democracy and Rule of Law Program at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. “Instead, we empowered and reinforced a mafia government, racked by cronyism.” Her book on the costs of corruption, “Thieves of State,” is based on her 10 years working in Afghanistan, including as an adviser to the US military.

Some of the push for serious anticorruption measures is coming from donors impatient with seeing billions in aid landing in corrupt private hands. But worldwide, a new generation of young people – frustrated with seeing their futures siphoned to Swiss bank accounts or expensive cars – are pressuring governments from the street. April’s anticorruption protests in Romania were organized by high school students. On March 26, anticorruption protests broke out in more than 90 Russian cities, with heavy representation among youth. A grade-schooler addressed protesters in the Siberian city of Tomsk.

“These protests on the street are very helpful, but what is more important is that civil societies develop the technical skills to understand what corruption is – and convince partners in the private sector that a corruption-free international market is much better for them,” says Peter Eigen, the founder of Transparency International, a leading anticorruption nongovernmental organization. 

Mr. Eigen, who worked with President Ghani on corruption issues at the World Bank in the 1990s, says that Ghani has the background to develop credible institutions and resources to deal with corruption.  

“There is a possibility to change things,” he adds. “But it will take a very strong coalition between a locally based civil society – not just do-gooders from Germany and the US – to deal with corruption and lift the standard of integrity. The national government cannot be the leader. It has to be in cooperation with an organized civil society that is becoming stronger and stronger, with more wisdom and more courage.”


A Christian Science Perspective

About this feature

Each weekday, the Monitor includes one clearly labeled religious article offering spiritual insight on contemporary issues, including the news. The publication – in its various forms – is produced for anyone who cares about the progress of the human endeavor around the world and seeks news reported with compassion, intelligence, and an essentially constructive lens. For many, that caring has religious roots. For many, it does not. The Monitor has always embraced both audiences. The Monitor is owned by a church – The First Church of Christ, Scientist, in Boston – whose founder was concerned with both the state of the world and the quality of available news.

Sometimes we may find ourselves feeling dislike or even hate for someone. But we are all capable of thinking and acting in accord with what God has created us as – the reflection of divine Love. “The Spirit itself beareth witness with our spirit, that we are the children of God,” the Apostle Paul wrote (Romans 8:16). It’s not right to tolerate or ignore hate-fueled actions. But recognizing that hatred is inconsistent with this true, spiritual identity can quiet fear, awaken thought to what’s right, and enable healing and reformation.


A message of love

Valentin Flauraud/Keystone/AP
A 'land art' painting of a Volkswagen Bus, by French artist Saype, took over a hill in Château d'Oex, Switzerland. The artwork, covering nearly 5,000 square yards, was produced using more than 100 gallons of biodegradable paint made from natural pigments, water, and a milk protein. The artwork is aimed at welcoming attendees of a VW festival here this coming weekend.
( The illustrations in today’s Monitor Daily are by Jacob Turcotte. )

A look ahead

Thanks for joining us today. Tomorrow, we'll home in on an eye-catching shift in the Middle East, where Saudi Arabia is making a full U-turn and aligning itself with Shiite-dominated Iraq.

More issues

2017
August
23
Wednesday

Give us your feedback

We want to hear, did we miss an angle we should have covered? Should we come back to this topic? Or just give us a rating for this story. We want to hear from you.