2022
July
27
Wednesday

Monitor Daily Podcast

July 27, 2022
Loading the player...

TODAY’S INTRO

Tour de France Femmes: Why equality in cycling is gaining momentum

At one point, while my family and I were living overseas, there were no team sports for girls at the school my daughters were attending. Only boys were given the opportunity to learn teamwork, perseverance, and confidence through athletics. When I volunteered to start a girls basketball team, I was told no – unless I started a boys team, too.

Perhaps that’s why the return of a Tour de France for women caught my eye. The premier cycling event is holding the first official women’s race in 33 years. The weeklong, 642-mile race began Sunday with 144 cyclists competing in 24 teams. The race has about $250,000 in total prize money, including $51,000 for the overall winner.

Yes, it’s shorter and less lucrative than the men’s race. But it’s still progress. Female cyclists have been campaigning for equality on two wheels for decades, sporadically holding official and unofficial races. For example, since 2015, a group of French women known as Donnons des Elles au Vélo (Give the Girls a Bike) has ridden every stage of the Tour – the day before the men’s race. 

Explanations for the inequality in cycling have sounded very similar to arguments made about U.S. women’s pro soccer and basketball – too few sponsors, not a big enough audience, etc. But as in soccer, a shift is underway. American Lily Williams started riding professionally in 2020. Two years later, she tells Sports Illustrated, “I’m making a full salary from the sport. And ... I can finish my race and go into our own personal team camper and take a shower. The whole sport has just grown leaps and bounds.”

Kate Veronneau at Zwift (the Tour de France Femmes sponsor) tells The Washington Post, “Women’s sports is trending hard because the companies that have invested in sports are seeing fabulous returns.” Equally important, she adds: “For little girls growing up and seeing themselves in a variety of sports ... that’s powerful.”

As a granddad, I agree. 

You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.

Husband, son, father, angel: A Ukrainian family mourns its hero

When a warrior falls, he or she often leaves loved ones behind. Our reporter takes an empathetic look at one Ukrainian family’s efforts to make sense of the sacrifice of a father and son. 

Scott Peterson/Getty Images/The Christian Science Monitor
Zhanna Palahniuk and her 6-year-old daughter, Yulianna, choose flowers to place on the grave of 1st Lt. Oleksandr Palahniuk in his rural home village of Pokutyne, south of Vinnytsia, Ukraine, as the family mourns the loss in late April of this Ukrainian paratrooper, June 21, 2022.
  • Quick Read
  • Deep Read ( 7 Min. )

Oleksandr Palahniuk’s family recalls him as a born problem-solver. Someone who grated against authority, yet found his calling in Ukraine’s military. Someone whose bulletproof confidence honed by years of combat inspired faith that he’d always come home. They sensed his doubts only at the very end.

In late April, three days after offering a Monitor correspondent an “excursion” to the front, First Lieutenant Palahniuk was killed when a Russian tank scored a direct hit on his armored vehicle in Kharkiv province. He was carrying orders to front-line troops – to not retreat.

“There was never even one thought that something like this could happen. Never,” says his wife, Zhanna, her arms folded protectively around their daughter Yulianna, both still reeling from the loss weeks later. “I was confident in him, that he could find a way out of any hard situation,” she says. “That’s how I coped.”

At the farmhouse in western Ukraine where Sasha, as he was called, was raised, the weight of the family’s sacrifice is clearly articulated.

“We have to keep living; we have to believe in victory, to understand that he didn’t go in vain,” says his father, Mykhailo. “Sasha defended us. That’s worth it. Sasha did something good; he meant something. We think he’s a hero.”

Husband, son, father, angel: A Ukrainian family mourns its hero

Collapse

Zhanna Palahniuk never doubted that her husband – a Ukrainian paratrooper whose bulletproof confidence was honed by years of combat – would be in the thick of the battle, or that he would always prevail.

Then, in late April, Russian forces engaging in a major new offensive bore down on 1st Lt. Oleksandr Palahniuk’s Ukrainian Army unit, on the Izyum front in northeastern Ukraine.

In daily video calls, he began telling his wife of serious challenges and morale-sapping shortages, even of vehicles. A born problem-solver, who grated against hierarchy yet found his calling in the military, the deputy company commander said he resorted to evacuating the wounded on his own motorcycle.

What he didn’t tell her was that the fight was becoming overwhelming – and that he had stepped on a landmine. The device clicked but did not detonate, momentarily sparing the experienced fighter from being added to Ukraine’s soaring daily death toll then of 100 to 200 soldiers.

“I could see that something happened, that he was really deep into his thoughts and depressed,” Mrs. Palahniuk recalls, her voice cracking at the memory of the decorated and exhausted paratrooper, called Sasha by all who knew him, who was long overdue for rotation.

“He was disappointed and stressed. He asked me to bring our daughter to the phone, so he could talk to her,” she says of 6-year-old Yulianna. “I made a screenshot of his face and sent it to him. I said, ‘Look at yourself now. You look pale, tired. ... You should look after yourself.’”

Scott Peterson/Getty Images/The Christian Science Monitor
A portrait of Ukrainian 1st Lt. Oleksandr Palahniuk, killed in late April, and training certificates are kept in his childhood bedroom in the rural village of Pokutyne, south of Vinnytsia, Ukraine, June 21, 2022. A nine-year veteran with extensive combat experience and American and other NATO training, the lieutenant is one face of a Ukrainian death toll that has reached as high as 200 soldiers a day.

If his wife could detect a trace of vulnerability, it was not something he projected in those days to strangers. Dressed for combat, in a brief encounter with this correspondent April 25 in Druzhkivka, Lt. Palahniuk’s handshake was strong and his bearing confident, showing he was no stranger to the front lines.

He offered an “excursion” to the front, then late the next day and again the following messaged that he could not meet because things had escalated dramatically.

On April 28 he was killed when a Russian tank scored a direct hit on his armored vehicle. He was at the village of Kurulky, in Kharkiv Province, carrying orders to front-line troops – not to retreat.

“There was never even one thought that something like this could happen. Never,” says Mrs. Palahniuk, her arms folded protectively around Yulianna, both still reeling from the loss weeks later.

“I was confident in him, that he could find a way out of any hard situation,” she says. “That’s how I coped.”

The weight of sacrifice

Amid the high casualty numbers from Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, the death of a single soldier may appear barely significant, adding just one statistical notch to the toll as this war enters its seventh month.

But, as in any conflict, behind every number is a human face and a colossal impact on each family, which is left to grapple with loss.

In the case of Ukraine, which is being defended against a more powerful aggressor, the weight of sacrifice is clearly articulated in the tidy farmhouse ringed with rose bushes where Sasha Palahniuk was raised, in the rural western village of Pokutyne, near the border with Moldova.

“We have to keep living, we have to believe in victory, to understand that he didn’t go in vain,” says the paratrooper’s father, Mykhailo Palahniuk, whose work on his 15-acre wheat, barley, and soy farm has left his face sun-kissed and his fingers cracked.

Scott Peterson/Getty Images/The Christian Science Monitor
Mykhailo Palahniuk holds flowers in the Ukrainian national colors at his home in the rural village of Pokutyne, south of Vinnytsia, Ukraine, before visiting the grave of his paratrooper son, June 21, 2022.

“Sasha died for Ukraine, he died so that something like Bucha would never happen again,” he says, referring to atrocities committed by Russian troops in the northern Kyiv suburb in March.

“We are Ukrainians, and Sasha defended us,” says the farmer. “That’s worth it. Sasha did something good, he meant something. We think he’s a hero.”

Despite the high personal cost, for this family and so many others, “without such a sacrifice” the country would be occupied by Russia, Mr. Palahniuk says, just as the Ukrainian peninsula of Crimea was captured in 2014 and then annexed by Moscow.

“We live differently, we just want our country to prosper, to live well. That’s all we want,” he says. Nearby a portrait of his son in military dress uniform sits beside a pillow bedecked with medals.

Preserved in Sasha’s former bedroom are pictures of him in fighting gear with a camouflaged head wrap, and several certificates of training with American and other NATO troops. There is a paratrooper beret, a live large-caliber round, and a pair of fake hand grenades, painted black.

“Sasha’s brothers-in-arms are really missing him, because there are very few people like him left,” he says.

High on the wall is a depiction of the winged Angel Gabriel.

Trying to cope

Less than 100 yards from the house, up a cobblestone road covered with cracked asphalt, is the cemetery on the southeast edge of the village. Ukrainian and battalion flags fly over Sasha’s grave.

It is piled high with flower arrangements, and when his family members visit – this time with flowers in the Ukrainian national colors of blue and yellow – they each silently touch and kiss the wooden cross. The official death announcement notes that the “enemy takes the best sons of Ukraine,” but adds: “Eternal memory, heroes don’t die!”

Scott Peterson/Getty Images/The Christian Science Monitor
Larysa and Mykhailo Palahniuk speak about coping with the loss of their son, Ukrainian paratrooper Oleksandr Palahniuk, at their home in Pokutyne, Ukraine, June 21, 2022. “We are Ukrainians, and Sasha defended us,” says Mr. Palahniuk. “That’s worth it. Sasha did something good, he meant something. We think he’s a hero.”

“It’s very hard for us; we are still trying to find a way to cope with it,” says Larysa Palahniuk, the lieutenant’s mother, her tearful face framed by a black headscarf.

“I can’t believe this happened to my son,” she says. “At the same time, we have part of his blood, we have someone to live for,” she adds, referring to her granddaughter.

The challenge of telling Yulianna the news fell to her mother. Throughout the war, the girl would ask: “Has Papa called?”

When her father failed to call on her birthday in early May – just a week after he was killed – Yulianna asked her mother why.

“Our father is already an angel,” she told her.

Weeks later, when the funeral had passed, Yulianna again asked why her father did not call.

Her mother then asked: “How do people become angels?” The girl replied: “So, was Father killed?”

It was an inevitable, excruciating moment: Yes, she was told.

A commander, not a farmer

Sasha was a “regular boy” who enjoyed fishing and camping, his parents recall. A special love was a 650cc motorcycle that still sits in a shed.

The officer-in-waiting rode the bike often, including to dances in nearby villages. But he detested farm work, dismissing it with a common Ukrainian aphorism, “This is not the business of the Czar.”

Sasha only went to college – where he met his wife – at the insistence of his mother.

“He was a commander,” Zhanna Palahniuk recalls of her husband-to-be. “Even when they lived with the boys in the dorm, he was giving orders and managing people, saying, ‘You will be washing dishes, you will be cleaning up,’ and everyone listened to him.”

He surprised her one day in 2013 when he signed up to join the army.

But he also disliked hierarchy, and would come back from training with callouses on his knuckles – from all the push-ups he did as punishment for not following orders.

He was sent to Crimea, and in the winter of 2014-15 was at the Donetsk Airport for a famous last-stand battle in the face of heavy Russian firepower.

“Sasha is a real warrior, and always was a real warrior,” his wife says.

Scott Peterson/Getty Images/The Christian Science Monitor
Zhanna Palahniuk kisses her daughter, Yulianna, as they speak about the April combat loss of her husband, Oleksandr Palahniuk, in a wooded park in Vinnytsia, Ukraine, June 20, 2022.

And while his aversion to what he sometimes considered to be “stupid” orders appears to have slowed his advance to the rank of captain, it helped endear him to men under his command. Indeed, as the war increasingly imposed its will on his unit in April, the lieutenant told his wife he felt he had saved his men’s lives three times by not following all orders.

He told his parents his unit was suffering “very big losses” and had no vehicles; friends even gathered money to donate a car.

Near the end, “Sasha said there was no exit,” says his father. “He said, ‘We have a task, but not the tools to do it.’”

On his last call to his parents, just days before his death, it was “clear something had changed,” recalls his mother. “I saw he wasn’t holding it together, he was down.

“We had an intuition,” she says. “We didn’t sleep all night.”

Neither, in those days, did his wife.

Zhanna Palahniuk today pulls her daughter in tight and kisses her nose, eliciting giggles.

“The child makes me laugh,” she says of her warrior husband’s “beautiful legacy.”

“At least he has a legacy,” she says. “There are many others who don’t.”

Oleksandr Naselenko supported reporting for this story.

‘No longer only conductors’: Ukraine’s rail workers play key war role

Here’s another story from Ukraine, where train conductors are often greeted with hugs from strangers. Our reporter rides the rails and finds a portrait of perseverance and adaptability in a time of war. 

Gleb Garanich/Reuters
A father says goodbye to his daughter as she boards a train to Dnipro and Lviv during an evacuation effort from war-affected areas of eastern Ukraine, amid Russia's invasion of the country, in Pokrovsk, Donetsk region, Ukraine, July 20, 2022.
  • Quick Read
  • Deep Read ( 6 Min. )

Before the Russian invasion on Feb. 24, Ukrainian Railways was better known for its halting bureaucracy than bringing people to safety.

Since then, the company has evacuated 4 million people from the country’s south, east, and center, and brought another half a million into neighboring countries. Its cars deliver military equipment and diplomats, ship goods amid the Black Sea blockade, and have carried some 100,000 tons of humanitarian aid.

Crises often expose an institution’s existing flaws – a trend so often seen during the COVID-19 pandemic. Ukrainian Railways’ success in the last five months is a moment where the crisis didn’t win. Facing artillery attacks, altered routes, and enemy occupation of 20% of its network, the country’s train system has adapted, kept running.

Svitlana Kravchuk, a 22-year-veteran train attendant based in Lviv, used to collect tickets and clean rooms. Now she consoles people fleeing their homes. She has worked as many evacuation routes as possible, barely taking a break for three weeks. When they had to stop to avoid shelling, she sometimes spent more than 24 hours on a train.

“We are no longer only conductors,” she says. “We sometimes have to be friends, psychologists, even parents for children.”

“The war is really changing everything.”

‘No longer only conductors’: Ukraine’s rail workers play key war role

Collapse

Oleksandr Kamyshin, the CEO of Ukraine’s state-owned train company and one of the country’s most powerful men, mingled in a crowd of about 60 children aged 10 to 16 and at least a dozen pets.

At the Children’s Railway, a Kyiv park complete with a miniature train station, they were all celebrating the many Ukrainian people and pets evacuated by rail. Students at the associated Children’s Railway School, training to one day work in the train system, had dressed appropriately in conductor outfits.

It was a fitting, rare few hours off for Mr. Kamyshin, wearing a navy polo and cargo pants himself. That week in June, he’d spent five of his last seven nights in an overnight car. So even on a morning he wasn’t working, what was one more short ride on the park’s short loop? Ukrainian Railways’ accomplishments, he says, should be celebrated.

“Before the war, [the railwayman profession didn’t have] that good of a reputation,” he says. “Now you say the term ‘railwayman’ and you will get a hug.”

Before February, Ukrainian Railways was better known for its halting bureaucracy than bringing people to safety. Since then, the company has evacuated 4 million people from the country’s south, east, and center, and brought another half a million into neighboring countries, says Mr. Kamyshin. Its cars deliver military equipment and diplomats, ship goods amid the Black Sea blockade, and have carried some 100,000 tons of humanitarian aid, he says. “Some people say that we are the second army because we ... are close to them in importance.”

Natacha Pisarenko/AP
A boy wearing a train guard uniform waits for the departure of a train at the Children's Railway in Kyiv, Ukraine, June 4, 2022. The Children's Railway lets children drive trains and learn about working in the railway industry.

Crises often expose an institution’s existing flaws – a trend so often seen during the COVID-19 pandemic. Ukrainian Railways’ success in the last five months is a moment where the crisis didn’t win. Facing artillery attacks, altered routes, and enemy occupation of 20% of its network, the country’s train system has adapted, kept running.

That work fits the zeitgeist in Ukraine right now – extraordinary perseverance meeting extraordinary challenges. Among so many other institutions also adapting, Ukrainian Railways has become a symbol of national pride even as it sustains the nation’s war effort. In the last five months, pronouncing its name, Ukrzaliznytsia, has become a way to prove a person’s Ukrainian accent.

“We’re just doing our job,” says Mr. Kamyshin. “It’s not something special. It’s not something heroic. We just don’t stop.”

“We are no longer only conductors”

On Feb. 23, Svitlana Kravchuk, a 22-year-veteran train attendant based in Lviv, was traveling on an overnight route to Odesa. Early in the morning, passengers woke to the news that their country was at war. When they arrived, the platform at Odesa’s station was already packed and panicked. People banged on windows as others crowded inside. Two hundred people fit into cars that usually carry 40. Many didn’t have space to sit down.

Ms. Kravchuk used to collect tickets and clean rooms. Now she had to console people fleeing their homes. She worked as many evacuation routes as possible, barely taking a break for three weeks. When they had to stop to avoid shelling, she sometimes spent more than 24 hours on a train.

“We are no longer only conductors,” she says. “We sometimes have to be friends, psychologists, even parents for children.”

“The war is really changing everything.”

For weeks, starting Feb. 24, Mr. Kamyshin measured his life in conference calls, speaking with regional traffic managers each hour. Those managers suddenly needed to manage bottlenecks at each station and artillery barrages that made travel more difficult.

As of June 8, the Kyiv School of Economics estimates that Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has caused some $2.7 billion in damage to railway infrastructure and rolling stock. About a fifth of the train system’s reach is now under occupied territory. Since February, according to Oleksandr Pertsovskyi, CEO of Ukrainian Railways’ passenger division, 170 of its employees have been killed. One of the worst moments of the war occurred when a Russian cluster bomb hit a train platform in Kramatorsk, killing almost 60.

Scott Peterson/Getty Images/The Christian Science Monitor
Scores of Ukrainian evacuees from the embattled city of Lysychansk board an evacuation train to safer cities to the west, from the train station in Pokrovsk, Ukraine, June 24, 2022. Russian invasion forces are focused on capturing the industrial Donbas region of Ukraine, after a failed attempt to seize the capital, Kyiv, in late February.

Still, given the train system’s importance to Ukraine’s war effort, it’s almost surprising that the Russian military hasn’t targeted such infrastructure more. After invading the country from multiple fronts this winter, the Russian attack has now concentrated on eastern Ukraine’s Donetsk region. It’s now under immense fire, and Russia for now may be content to damage more infrastructure in fewer places.

Of course, the Russian military is highly dependent on trains for its own supplies. Many speculate that it has avoided targeting Ukrainian rail infrastructure in the hope that it will be able to make use of it later, should the war go Russia’s way.

Or, the train system may just be too big a target. “We have thousands of important places in the railway [system],” says Denys Rynski, a volunteer who helped coordinate logistics for Lviv’s train station. “It’s impossible to bomb all of them.”

“We have to find a way to keep a sense of normalcy”

When the train system is bombed a few things happen immediately, says Mr. Pertsovskyi, the passenger head. As soon as it’s safe, teams deploy to assess the damage and start repairs. A regional traffic manager reroutes the delayed train and others to limit disruptions. A dispatch team communicates with the conductor, who communicates with the attendants, who communicate with the passengers. Everyone on board gets free food and drinks.

“Part of this calmness is that people are not asking questions,” says Mr. Pertsovskyi. “They’re just doing their job.”

He compares them to Capt. Chesley “Sully” Sullenberger, the US Airways pilot who emergency-landed a passenger plane in the Hudson River.  

In Ukraine, the emergency isn’t just one day, one flight, or one ride. It’s every day, and it looks like it will be for a while. “Even during the war, we have to live on,” says Mr. Kamyshin. “We have to find a way to keep a sense of normalcy in our lives.”

That’s come at the cost of normalcy in his own life. Riding around the short loop at the Children’s Railway, in the small train decorated with pictures of Minecraft and Thomas the Tank Engine, Mr. Kamyshin keeps silencing phone calls. But one he picks up. For a few minutes, he looks only at the small screen in his hand, pointing the camera around the car. 

It’s one of his two sons. During the war, Mr. Kamyshin has only seen his family three times. “That’s one of the worst things in this war for me,” he says. “I’ve got two boys and I really miss them.”

To him, the sacrifice is worth it. To others, it has been as well.

For weeks, Oleksa Vozniak volunteered to help serve refugees arriving at the Lviv train station. Early in the war, some 50,000 people would show up each day, more than 10 times the usual number of arrivals in pre-war days. They needed places to eat, sleep, and stay warm during winter. Mr. Vozniak learned he could work 24 hours straight.

But in a country with so many different regions and regional identities, he saw something he’d never seen before: a mix of Ukrainians coexisting from all over Ukraine. Some refugees later became volunteers too. Ukraine’s train system, he says, helped make Ukraine.

“This is the place, this is the time when the Ukrainian nation was built, because I saw so many people volunteering,” says Mr. Vozniak.

“There is no difference between a person who is from Kramatorsk or from Dnipro or from Lviv,” he says. “This is just one united nation.”

Oleksandr Naselenko in Lviv and Olya Bystritskaya in Kyiv supported reporting for this story.

Frozen bank accounts and unfinished homes: China’s ‘desperate situation’

In any business deal or agreement, there’s a bond of trust – that each party will live up to its word. In China, our reporter looks at why trust in banks, homebuilders, and public health may be unraveling.

  • Quick Read
  • Deep Read ( 5 Min. )

Recently, clients of small-sized banks in the central Chinese province of Hunan were horrified to discover that their COVID-19 health codes had been switched to red – meaning they aren’t allowed to travel – in a ham-handed effort to stem growing protests over account freezes at China’s struggling local banks.  

The scandal is just one sign of the middle class’s waning confidence in Beijing’s promises of ever-rising prosperity. Chinese homebuyers are also threatening to boycott mortgage payments for some 320 unfinished housing projects across the country. 

Beijing has pressed provincial governments to address the banking and housing-project crises, seeking to avoid setting a precedent by footing the bill. But some authorities have responded with controversial tactics that further undermine people’s trust in government – such as manipulating the COVID-19 health code system and using plainclothes enforcers to beat protesters.

“From the party standpoint, anything that’s organized that’s not under party control is seen as a threat,” says Bruce Dickson, a political scientist at George Washington University. “At the local level, [changing peoples’ health codes] might be a clever strategy to deal with an immediate problem. But ... once you’ve done that, you’ve destroyed so much of the public trust.”

Frozen bank accounts and unfinished homes: China’s ‘desperate situation’

Collapse
Reuters
A screen grab from a video shows demonstrators holding up signs during a protest over the freezing of deposits by some rural-based banks, outside a People's Bank of China building in Zhengzhou, Henan province, China, on July 10, 2022. The sign in the foreground reads, "Henan Bank, return to us our legal deposits! The people's life-savings deposits!"

Wu Jian’s collapse of confidence in China’s local banks started with a click on his cellphone.

It was mid-June, and Mr. Wu was at home in the central Chinese city of Wuhan, preparing to go to neighboring Henan province to protest a freeze on his accounts by two struggling banks there that is threatening a big chunk of his family’s savings. 

But when the information technology professional checked his health code – a QR code showing COVID-19 risk status – he was shocked to see it had turned from green to red, meaning he was barred from traveling. He soon discovered he was not alone – more than 1,300 frustrated depositors and consumers from around the country, sharing information on China’s WeChat messaging app, had also received unexpected red codes in a ham-handed move by Henan authorities to block anti-bank demonstrations, which had already been breaking out around the province.

“I was pretty surprised,” Mr. Wu says. “You resort to this kind of a trick to stop people – doesn’t that mean you won’t give us our money back?” 

The Henan bank scandal highlights growing concerns over China’s more than 300 high-risk local banks, and it isn’t the only sign of waning trust in a key sector of China’s economy. Recent weeks have also seen a national wave of mortgage boycotts, as people stop or threaten to halt payments on homes purchased in advance as part of now-delayed housing construction. 

The confidence of middle-class Chinese like Mr. Wu in Beijing’s promises of ever-rising prosperity is waning, as they are increasingly paying a price for the country’s economic slowdown after decades of debt-fueled growth. Moving to protect their money and property, they are exerting leverage with their pocketbooks, organizing on social media, and even taking to the streets with legitimate demands to safeguard their hard-earned resources. 

“One of the new things ... is that it’s a middle-class phenomenon, not the type of labor strike or farmer protest that we’re used to seeing,” says Bruce Dickson, a political scientist at George Washington University. “This is people who’ve got a very legitimate gripe that they put their money down and the builders have not finished their homes to be able to move into. And the last resort is to stop paying,” he says, referring to the mortgage strikes. 

Reuters
A screen grab from a video shows uniformed and plainclothes security personnel running toward demonstrators outside a People's Bank of China building in Zhengzhou, Henan province, China, on July 10, 2022. Some authorities have responded to protests with controversial tactics, such as manipulating the COVID-19 health code system and using plainclothes enforcers to beat protesters.

Yet some authorities have responded with controversial tactics that further undermine people’s trust in government – such as manipulating the COVID-19 health code system, using plainclothes enforcers to beat protesters, and imposing stiff penalties through China’s sweeping social credit system. 

“From the party standpoint, anything that’s organized that’s not under party control is seen as a threat,” says Dr. Dickson, author of “The Party and the People: Chinese Politics in the 21st Century.” “At the local level, [changing people’s health codes] might be a clever strategy to deal with an immediate problem. But ... once you’ve done that, you’ve destroyed so much of the public trust that public health depends on.”

A middle-class mortgage strike

From Liaoning province in the north to Guangdong in the south, Chinese homebuyers are threatening to boycott mortgage payments for some 320 unfinished housing projects in more than 100 localities, according to an online tally of the growing strike.

In China, more than 85% of homes are sold months or years before construction is complete. Many Chinese families invest a large portion of their savings into these homes, encouraged to do so by the government and by decades of steadily rising housing prices. At the heart of the boycott that has surged in recent weeks are buyers’ doubts that debt-strapped developers will ever complete their promised homes. 

“People who are actually threatening to not pay are in a little bit [of a] desperate situation,” says Liqian Ren, an economist who hosts a podcast on China and Asian markets and works as a quantitative investment specialist at WisdomTree Asset Management in New York. “Because they are not getting the house they were promised, they have to rent a house on the side and still pay the mortgage.”

And although the mortgage boycott still represents a small share of the overall mortgage market, it and other debt problems could worsen if China’s economic slowdown continues.

Beijing, alarmed by the spreading movement, has started censoring social media discussions about the mortgage strike and deleting shared files tracking its scale.

Yet unless the government intervenes with more concrete steps to boost resources for homebuilders, analysts say, the boycott could snowball as jittery banks withhold credit to China’s troubled property sector, further delaying houses and causing more people to stop paying mortgages. 

Real estate makes up more than a quarter of China’s economy, but has been hurt by policies such as a regulatory crackdown on credit and China’s growth-stifling zero-COVID-19 policy. China’s economy grew 0.4% in the second quarter, marking a two-year low.

Who foots the bill?

Beijing has pressed provincial governments to address the banking and housing-project crises, seeking to avoid setting a precedent by footing the bill. “If the central government steps in, the local government has no incentive” to act, says Dr. Ren.

Sheldon Cooper/SOPA Images/Sipa USA/Reuters
Cranes are seen at a construction site in Jiangsu, China, on June 14, 2022. The vast majority of Chinese homes are sold months or years before construction is complete, but lately, buyers are feeling doubtful that debt-strapped developers will ever finish their promised homes.

Provincial authorities in Henan and neighboring Anhui province last week started repaying smaller victims of the recent banking scandal – those with deposits of $7,400 or less – and also reportedly pledged to refund deposits of up to $14,800 starting this week. They have also punished five local officials over the scandal.

But China’s highly indebted local governments are in a tight spot. They have been hit particularly hard by the real estate crisis because they depend on revenue from land sales. Meanwhile, the zero-COVID-19 policy has imposed new burdens on local leaders.

“Localities are having to bear the cost of all the COVID testing and other COVID-related policies. That is a big chunk,” says Jean Oi, a professor of Chinese politics at Stanford University. “Their revenues have suffered severely.”

“So as the economy keeps tanking with the continued lockdowns ... the center is going to have to start intervening,” she says. “You can’t just lay it all on localities.”

For his part, Mr. Wu agrees. “We hope the central government can take action, because everyone knows Henan province handles its own problems badly,” he says.

Mr. Wu hopes he will recover the $110,000 he deposited in the Henan banks. But if he does, he vows to never put it back into any of China’s nearly 4,000 small and medium-sized banks. 

“If I get the money back, I may put it in the ‘big four’ banks,” he says, referring to China’s largest national banks. More than likely, though, “I will exchange it for cash and keep it in my house,” he says with a laugh.

Patterns

Tracing global connections

Hello? Hello? Washington finds it hard to get through to Beijing.

Better communication means better understanding, more transparency, and less risk of mishaps. Our London columnist suggests Washington and Beijing need the kind of crisis management tools used during the Cold War.

  • Quick Read
  • Deep Read ( 4 Min. )

What the world needs now is a new Cold War.

That might sound crazy, but at least the rules of that war, the intricate shared architecture of state-to-state interaction and crisis management that Washington and Moscow built together, largely kept the peace and prevented a “hot” war.

But no such habits of communication have developed between the United States and its new superpower rival, China. There are no guardrails to prevent their competition from degenerating into conflict.

President Joe Biden and his senior officials have been trying to persuade Chinese leader Xi Jinping to start talking about practical ways in which the two countries might ensure strategic stability, but they have not had much success.

Mr. Biden will take up the issue tomorrow, in a phone call with Mr. Xi, not least because tensions around Taiwan, which Beijing regards as part of its territory, have risen sharply. The Chinese government is furious with U.S. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s reported plan to visit Taiwan, and the White House is not keen on it, either.

Such spats would be easier to manage if Washington and Beijing enjoyed robust avenues of communication that might offer mutual understanding. At the moment, the relationship is dangerously opaque.

Hello? Hello? Washington finds it hard to get through to Beijing.

Collapse
Andy Wong/AP
A Chinese couple ride on an electric bike with decals of the American flag in southwestern China's Yunnan province on July 16, 2022.

What the world needs now is a new Cold War.

Yes, you read that right.

And jarring though it will sound to those who remember Cold War I, it is that thought that is motivating intensified U.S. efforts to prevent a contentious relationship with China from becoming steadily – perhaps dangerously – worse.

This is not about pining for a reprise of the U.S-Soviet Cold War. It is simply acknowledging that Washington and Beijing are already locked in superpower competition, but they lack Cold War-style “guardrails” around their rivalry to prevent it from breaking down into hot war.

What’s still largely missing from the U.S.-China relationship is what might be called the “good” part of the old Cold War: the intricate shared architecture of state-to-state interaction and crisis management built up with Moscow; the arms talks and hotlines; the latticework of political and diplomatic and military exchanges; the regular summits and other high-level meetings that preserved the peace.

A reliable fabric of frank, forthright communication.

With Moscow, that had the long-term aim of narrowing differences. But it had a more immediate, practical objective: to ensure that each superpower adversary understood the other’s thinking and its “red lines” well enough to avoid potentially dangerous miscalculations, and an accidental escalation.

The absence of such understanding and trust when it comes to China has been worrying President Joe Biden since he entered the Oval Office 18 months ago. He and his top officials have been pressing Beijing to begin building crash barriers around their competition to stop it from degenerating into conflict.

But there’s been little sign of progress so far. And as Mr. Biden prepares for a phone call with Chinese leader Xi Jinping on Thursday, with an eye to a possible in-person meeting in November, a number of factors have ramped up his administration’s urgent search for ways to reduce the chance of potential miscalculations on either side.

Alex Brandon, Eraldo Peres/AP/File
U.S. President Joe Biden in Washington, Nov. 6, 2021, and Chinese leader Xi Jinping in Brasília, Brazil, Nov. 13, 2019. Mr. Biden is planning to speak on Thursday with his Chinese counterpart for the first time in four months, with a wide range of bilateral and international issues on the table. Communications between Beijing and Washington are poor.

The immediate issue is the democratic island state of Taiwan, which Mr. Xi is on record as saying will eventually be “reunified” with mainland China, by force if necessary.

For the last few months, Washington’s overriding focus on the Ukraine war has overshadowed its concern over Taiwan. The hope has been that Russian President Vladimir Putin’s failure to win a lightning victory in Ukraine might give Mr. Xi pause in considering any military action of his own.

That may well be true.

U.S. officials have been encouraged by the Chinese leader’s response to Mr. Biden’s explicit request in March that he show restraint on Ukraine. There are no signs that China has helped resupply Mr. Putin’s military, and major Chinese businesses have largely abided by Western sanctions against Moscow.

There was also a symbolic show of superpower amity in recent days: Mr. Xi responded to the announcement that Mr. Biden had tested positive for COVID-19 by wishing him a speedy recovery.

Still, the Chinese military has recently been far more assertive in confrontations with U.S. naval patrols exercising their right to sail in the South China Sea, which Mr. Xi has unilaterally claimed as Chinese territory.

And on Taiwan, there’s a new, potentially fractious, point of dispute: reported plans by U.S. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi to make an official visit to Taiwan next month – prompting Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesperson Zhao Lijan to vow “firm and forceful measures” if the trip goes ahead.

Though ultimately the decision on whether to go rests with Ms. Pelosi, the White House has made clear it would be happier if she delayed the trip.

One key reason is a potentially unpredictable political context inside China itself.

Mr. Xi’s attention is focused on a Communist Party congress in the fall, at which he is widely expected to secure an unprecedented third term in power. The concern among U.S. experts is that, especially at a time when Mr. Xi’s pandemic restrictions have led to a slowdown in economic growth, he might be more likely to indulge in a show of military assertiveness against Taiwan.

President Biden’s conversation with Mr. Xi tomorrow may clarify some of these uncertainties. Other long-standing issues of contention, such as whether Mr. Biden may start to ease his predecessor’s trade sanctions against China, could also come up.

But the new dispute over Taiwan has served to reinforce U.S. concern over the more fundamental problem in the relationship with China: its opaqueness, and the lack of sufficiently robust avenues of communication to offer mutual understanding amid inevitable points of disagreement.

Mr. Biden is almost certain to make that case again in his talks with Mr. Xi. One indication of potential progress would be an agreement to open talks on “strategic stability” between the rival powers, which Washington sees as a foundation stone of a Cold War-type architecture of communication.

That could be a step toward the broader U.S. aim, which Mr. Biden first put directly to the Chinese leader late last year – a set of “commonsense” agreements to “ensure that competition does not veer into conflict.”

Points of Progress

What's going right

What a view: More starlit skies and a mapped ocean floor

A key ingredient of progress is cooperation. In our latest Points of Progress roundup, we see groups working together to create the world’s biggest urban garden, skies free of light pollution, and a deeper understanding of our oceans.

What a view: More starlit skies and a mapped ocean floor

Collapse

There’s progress from the skies to ocean depths – and in between. The cooperation of neighbors in Rio de Janeiro to grow food near home has led to plans to knit together separate green spaces to make a large city farm. 

1. Brazil

Rio de Janeiro is building the world’s largest urban garden following success with community gardening. Large-scale community gardens have thrived in vulnerable neighborhoods of the city in recent years, even transforming a former dump into organic plots of cassava and other vegetables.

Last year, the municipal government announced plans to connect two existing gardens at either end of a 4.5-kilometer (2.8-mile) park in a move that is estimated to help feed 50,000 local families. The greenway displaced informal subsistence gardens when it was built in 2012.

Silvia Izquierdo/AP
Candida Valeria holds up a beetroot she harvested at a community garden in the Madureira neighborhood of Rio de Janeiro.

The new project is helping to “reclaim the area,” said Julio Cesar Barros, coordinator of Carioca Gardens, which supports 55 community gardens across Rio de Janeiro. Gardeners from five local favelas will tend the new garden for a stipend, donating half the produce to their communities. While coordinating with residents’ associations and municipal authorities and navigating networks of local drug traffickers poses challenges, residents are enthusiastic about the project. Without his local garden, Ezequiel Dias Areas said, “I might be selling drugs, I might be dead, I might be in prison.”
Source: Positive News

2. United States

More companies are partnering with historically Black colleges and universities to expand professional opportunities for their graduates. Many corporations have been working to diversify their staffs for years, but a nationwide demand for greater racial equity after the 2020 murder of George Floyd accelerated efforts. Organizations such as Google, IBM, United, and the NFL are teaming up with HBCUs for recruitment as well as investing in courses, technology, and mentorship to support the next generation of Black individuals and other people of color.

Carolyn Kaster/AP
Jasmine Marchbanks-Owens is a law student at Howard University in Washington, D.C., one of the oldest and largest HBCUs in the United States.

The country’s 102 HBCUs train 50% of Black lawyers, 40% of Black engineers, and 12.5% of Black CEOs, according to data from the Thurgood Marshall College Fund. The push to tap into these talent networks is being driven indirectly by consumers. “Especially for those companies that are consumer brands, their customers are saying that they want to see something happen,” said David Marshall, chair of the department of strategic communication at Morgan State University.
Source: The Hechinger Report

3. Antarctica

The most precise map yet of the Southern Ocean floor paves the way for safer navigation and more robust conservation. Scientists developed the International Bathymetric Chart of the Southern Ocean over the past five years, combining their own data with contributions from governments, institutions, and ships that navigate the waters. The map covers 77 million square kilometers (47.8 million square miles) of underwater canyons, mountains, and plains around Antarctica and includes the deepest depression discovered to date: the Factorian Deep, which is 7,432 meters (24,383 feet) down.

The first comprehensive chart, published in 2013, mapped the area of the ocean floor around Antarctica up to the latitude of 60 degrees south. This map expands the coverage to the 50-degree line, which scientists say more than doubles the area of the chart, and will help researchers better manage fisheries, protect biodiversity hot spots, and refine climate models. The project received funding from Japan’s Nippon Foundation and Seabed 2030, an international campaign to chart the globe’s ocean floor by the end of the decade. In the future, robotic vessels may be able to map the most inaccessible regions of the Antarctic sea.
Sources: BBC, Scientific Data

4. Tunisia

Ons Jabeur became the first Arab woman to compete in a Grand Slam tennis championship final. Ms. Jabeur began telling friends she was going to win the French Open when she was 9 – an ambition that earned little more than chuckles at the time. This year, the tennis star reached No. 2 in the world before making it to the Wimbledon singles final, where she lost to Elena Rybakina.

Kirsty Wigglesworth/AP
Tunisia’s Ons Jabeur serves to Kazakhstan’s Elena Rybakina during the Wimbledon tennis championships in London, July 9, 2022.

No woman from Africa had ever made the Women’s Tennis Association’s top 10 rankings before Ms. Jabeur earned her spot last year. At home, she is known as “Wazeerat Al Sa’ada,” or the “Minister of Happiness,” among her fans. “I want to see more players from my country, from the Middle East, from Africa,” said Ms. Jabeur. “I think we didn’t believe enough at [a] certain point that we can do it. Now I’m just trying to show that.”
Sources: The Washington Post, WBUR

World

A record number of dark-sky protection areas are defending against light pollution. The International Dark-Sky Association was founded in 1988 by two astronomers committed to safeguarding the skies from excessive light pollution, which has risen 49% in the past 25 years. Research suggests that light pollution negatively impacts animals, plants, and ecosystems.
Achieving dark-sky status often begins with a small group of dedicated community members, and generally takes between one and three years, including official assessments, light measurements, and review processes. The first International Dark Sky Place was inaugurated in Flagstaff, Arizona, in 2001. Since then, 195 sites across all six inhabited continents have been certified by the association, totaling over 110,000 square kilometers (42,471 square miles) of sky.
Sources: BBC, International Dark-Sky Association

Other headline stories we’re watching

(Get live updates throughout the day.)

The Monitor's View

Democracy’s gain in the Middle East

  • Quick Read
  • Deep Read ( 2 Min. )

In Tunisia, where the Arab uprising against autocracy began a decade ago, voters approved a new constitution on Monday that gives the president unchecked powers. That marks an about-face for a country that just eight years ago adopted a progressive legal canon after 24 years of dictatorship.

Tunisia’s turn may reflect a regional trend. A new survey of Arab public opinion found instability and weak economies are eroding trust in democracy across the Middle East. Yet in one important way, the annual Arab Barometer noted, the country remains a pacesetter: It saw the greatest increase in the percentage of citizens – from 40% in 2018 to 56% now – who support female leaders.

Most of that gain has come since the rise last September of Najla Bouden, a geology professor, as the Arab world’s first female prime minister.

Not all the Arab Barometer’s conclusions are hopeful. It found that 61% of Tunisians think violence against women has risen. But two of its main findings – declining confidence in democracy and growing support for female leaders – may be two sides of the same coin. They show that the popular aspirations for equality and good governance that poured into the streets a decade ago remain.

Democracy’s gain in the Middle East

Collapse
AP
A woman holds up a banner during a protest in Tunis, the capital of Tunisia. The country voted Monday for a new constitution expanding presidential powers.

In Tunisia, where the Arab uprising against autocracy began a decade ago, democracy has suffered an apparent setback. Voters approved a new constitution on Monday that gives the president unchecked powers. That marks an about-face for a country that just eight years ago adopted a progressive legal canon based on “freedom, dignity, justice, and order” after 24 years of dictatorship.

Tunisia’s turn may reflect a regional trend. A new survey of Arab public opinion found instability and weak economies are eroding trust in democracy across the Middle East and North Africa. More than 50% of Arabs express a lack of confidence in elected government, as do 7 in 10 Tunisians. Yet in one important way, the annual Arab Barometer noted, Tunisia remains a pacesetter: It saw the greatest increase in the percentage of citizens – from 40% in 2018 to 56% now – who support female leaders.

Most of that gain has come since the rise last September of Najla Bouden, a geology professor, as the Arab world’s first female prime minister. “We didn’t see a drastic shift in public opinion on women’s rights prior to this appointment,” Amaney Jamal, Arab Barometer co-founder and dean of Princeton’s School of Public and International Affairs, told the BBC. Ms. Bouden’s prominence has “allowed people to say, ‘Guess what, women can be just as effective as political leaders as their male counterparts.’”

By one metric, the number of seats held by women in Arab parliaments, their gains appear modest. Since 2010, prior to the uprisings, female legislators in the region have increased from 10% to about 16%. In some countries, quotas have made a difference. The United Arab Emirates, for example, now requires gender parity in its parliament.

But representation alone may offer too narrow a view. Female civil rights activists fill prominent leadership roles in pro-democracy movements in countries like Iran and Sudan. Female filmmakers from Morocco to Kuwait are transforming narratives of the region. Their works are reaching a wider audience. Earlier this month, Netflix released 21 movies by Arab female directors.

“Women filmmakers have beautiful, complex, and nuanced stories to tell – stories which have the power to resonate with people not just in the Arab world, but across the globe,” the streaming company said. One depicts a young girl yearning for a normal childhood in the shadow of her father’s fanatical beliefs.

Not all the Arab Barometer’s conclusions are hopeful. It found that 61% of Tunisians, for example, think violence against women has risen. But two of its main findings – declining confidence in democracy and growing support for female leaders – may be two sides of the same coin. They show that the popular aspirations for equality and good governance that poured into the streets a decade ago remain.

A Christian Science Perspective

About this feature

Each weekday, the Monitor includes one clearly labeled religious article offering spiritual insight on contemporary issues, including the news. The publication – in its various forms – is produced for anyone who cares about the progress of the human endeavor around the world and seeks news reported with compassion, intelligence, and an essentially constructive lens. For many, that caring has religious roots. For many, it does not. The Monitor has always embraced both audiences. The Monitor is owned by a church – The First Church of Christ, Scientist, in Boston – whose founder was concerned with both the state of the world and the quality of available news.

Walking hand in hand with God

  • Quick Read
  • Read or Listen ( 3 Min. )

Getting to know God as more than an abstraction makes His healing power, presence, and love a more tangible part of our daily lives.

Walking hand in hand with God

Collapse
Today's Christian Science Perspective audio edition

How I admired my next-door neighbor, Joyce. She loved God. And it showed. On her kitchen wall hung a plaque that said, “Nothing can happen today that the Lord and I can’t handle.” For Joyce, life was a day-by-day walking hand in hand with God. I wanted to feel that close to God, too.

I’d learned in Christian Science Sunday School that God is Love. In fact, I’d learned seven Bible-based names for God that describe His nature: Love, Principle, Mind, Spirit, Soul, Life, and Truth. But they were just words to me; they seemed textbook-y. I vowed right then and there to give them attention.

I’d just begun reading a biography of Mary Baker Eddy, a follower of Christ Jesus and the discoverer of Christian Science. I saw that God was her constant companion, and she looked to Him for everything – for direction, protection, correction, and healing.

There’s a simple analogy Mrs. Eddy gives in her book “Science and Health with Key to the Scriptures”: that each of us is to God as a ray of light is to the sun (see p. 361). A ray of light can’t be unready, unable, or unwilling to shine. It can’t have any gaps in its shining. It can’t fizzle out from shining, either. All it can do is shine. Just as you can’t have a ray of light without the sun, neither can you have the sun without its rays.

So as God’s spiritual reflection – made in God’s very image, spiritual and perfect as our Maker, and always connected to Him – we are as important and precious to God as He is to us.

With this inspiration (straight from God!), my relationship to God became more important and more real to me. Taking those seven names for God, I began to think of man (which includes everyone) as God’s shining, and began to claim this closeness to God for myself:

As Mind’s shining, we express understanding and clarity.

As Principle’s shining, we express certainty and invariability.

As Soul’s shining, we express joy and satisfaction.

As Spirit’s shining, we express substantiality and strength.

As Truth’s shining, we express perfection and freedom.

As Life’s shining, we express vitality and spontaneity.

As Love’s shining, we are the very loved of Love, loving and lovely in every way.

All of these are true for each of us, for we are His.

Those seven names for God were now beginning to mean something profound to me. God was so much more than a three-letter word. Not long after, I took Primary class instruction in Christian Science. And that’s when those names really came to life!

That was years ago, but I still often enjoy making a new, spontaneous list – inspired, not intellectual – of God’s qualities, with the goal of expressing them more fully. This makes every day an experience of walking hand in hand with God. It shows me how palpable is God’s presence, how ready is His power. Everything we do all day can be done with God, by God, for God – to glorify God.

Some days I enjoy focusing on one of His names in particular. For instance, that biography quoted Mrs. Eddy as saying, “The first thing I do in the morning when I awake is to declare I shall have no other mind before divine Mind and become fully conscious of this and then adhere to it throughout the entire day. Then the evil cannot touch me” (Robert Peel, “Mary Baker Eddy: The Years of Authority,” p. 242).

What becoming “fully conscious of this” says to me is, Then not one confused, fearful, mean, anxious, stupid, or selfish thought is truly mine. Recognizing such thoughts as counterfeits of the divine Mind empowers us to rise above them. As the Apostle Paul said, “We have the mind of Christ” (I Corinthians 2:16). The Mind of Christ – that’s God.

As I continue to grow in my understanding of God, my desire to obey His will grows too, and also my conviction that God’s will for all is just as good as He is. In Mrs. Eddy’s “Miscellaneous Writings 1883-1896” is this invitation and promise: “Those who know no will but His take His hand, and from the night He leads to light” (p. 347).

Care to join me in taking God’s hand today?

A message of love

Amelia Earhart lands in Washington

J. Scott Applewhite/AP
Kansas Gov. Laura Kelly (center) is joined by House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (center left), Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (far left), and former Kansas Sen. Jerry Moran (center right) for the dedication and unveiling ceremony of a statue in honor of Amelia Earhart, one of the world's most celebrated aviators and the first woman to fly solo across the Atlantic Ocean, in Statuary Hall, at the Capitol in Washington, July 27, 2022. The statue of Amelia Earhart will represent the State of Kansas in the National Statuary Hall Collection.
( The illustrations in today’s Monitor Daily are by Jacob Turcotte. )

A look ahead

Thanks for joining us. Come back tomorrow for a review of a new Ron Howard film about the perseverance and problem-solving that resulted in the rescue of a Thai student soccer team trapped in a flooded cave in 2018.

More issues

2022
July
27
Wednesday

Give us your feedback

We want to hear, did we miss an angle we should have covered? Should we come back to this topic? Or just give us a rating for this story. We want to hear from you.